The daughter of Jay Broughton, back right, and Bernard Holbrook's wife, front right, are comforted after Broughton was killed by two gunshot wounds Wednesday on Bull Creek Road near Adelphi. He was allegedly shot once in the abdomen and once in the chest by Holbrook, his brother-in-law. According to Ross County Sheriff’s Det. David Bower, the two had been involved in a dispute that had been going on for more than a year and were not in close contact despite living just a few doors away from one another.